Oregon’s two United States senators have joined a congressional effort to remove provisions from the nation’s annual defense authorization legislation that would expand military technology partnerships and intelligence cooperation with Israel, bringing questions of American national security independence, foreign military commitments and presidential authority into negotiations over the federal government’s defense priorities.
U.S. Senators Ron Wyden and Jeff Merkley announced Monday, November 16, that they are pressing congressional leadership to eliminate three provisions from the Fiscal Year 2027 National Defense Authorization Act. The proposed requirements would establish expanded defense technology partnerships between the United States and Israel while placing statutory conditions on the president’s ability to reduce certain intelligence-sharing arrangements.
The congressional challenge involves some of the most sensitive areas of American military development, including artificial intelligence, autonomous weapons systems, biotechnology, quantum computing, cybersecurity and advanced defense manufacturing. The senators contend that mandatory cooperation could create technological dependencies that would complicate future American military decisions and diminish Washington’s flexibility in responding to changing international security conditions.
The effort originated in a November 10 letter led by Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen and signed by 11 additional senators, including Wyden and Merkley. The correspondence was directed to congressional leaders responsible for negotiating the final defense legislation, among them Senate Majority Leader John Thune, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, House Speaker Mike Johnson and House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries.
The senators are seeking removal of Section 1217 from the Senate Armed Services Committee’s defense legislation, Section 219 from the House-passed measure and Section 618 from intelligence authorization legislation that could be incorporated into the final defense package.
The first two provisions would establish a United States-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative intended to accelerate joint military research, weapons development, industrial production and the integration of emerging technologies into American defense systems. The proposals would involve government agencies, private defense contractors, research institutions and manufacturing partnerships in both countries.
The proposed initiative would extend cooperation into technologies that increasingly influence military operations, intelligence gathering, battlefield communications and the development of sophisticated weapons systems. Joint research and production arrangements could also affect how military equipment is acquired, manufactured and maintained over extended periods.
Supporters of the initiative have argued that closer technological cooperation would strengthen military innovation, improve interoperability between American and Israeli defense systems and accelerate development of capabilities needed to counter emerging security threats. The legislation also contains provisions addressing the protection of sensitive technologies and national security information.
Wyden, Merkley and their colleagues contend that requiring such arrangements through federal law could produce consequences beyond the immediate development of new military capabilities. Their objections center on the possibility that American defense systems could become increasingly dependent on Israeli technology, manufacturing arrangements and intellectual property, making future changes to military procurement or foreign policy more difficult.
The senators also question whether Congress should compel the executive branch to establish additional cooperative agreements when the president already possesses authority to pursue bilateral defense arrangements under existing law.
Their letter argues that the United States should retain the ability to evaluate foreign military partnerships independently, particularly when the policies of a foreign government conflict with American strategic objectives.
The disagreement extends beyond defense manufacturing into the intelligence community.
Section 618 would require the executive branch to expand intelligence sharing with Israel across a broad range of security matters, including terrorism, cyber threats, missile defense, military activities and regional security developments. The proposed language would also establish conditions governing decisions to suspend, reduce or otherwise materially limit intelligence exchanges.
Under the intelligence-sharing proposal, reductions could still occur when the president identifies a specific national security concern. Such decisions would require documentation, and significant changes would trigger congressional notification requirements.
The Oregon senators and their colleagues maintain that these statutory conditions would unnecessarily restrict presidential discretion over sensitive intelligence relationships. They argue that decisions involving classified information, intelligence sources and national security threats must remain responsive to changing circumstances rather than be governed by a standing congressional requirement favoring expanded cooperation.
The debate has particular significance because intelligence relationships frequently involve information that cannot be publicly disclosed, including surveillance capabilities, military assessments, intelligence collection methods and operational planning. Decisions to expand or restrict those exchanges can affect American personnel, military operations and relationships with other foreign governments.
The senators’ objections also reflect growing disagreements in Congress over American policy toward Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, particularly concerning military operations in Gaza, developments in the West Bank and the broader regional conflict involving Iran.
In their correspondence, the senators argue that Israel’s recent policies have increasingly conflicted with American interests. They also raise concerns about whether expanding joint defense production would give Israel additional influence over decisions involving American military equipment.
One example cited in the congressional letter involves American-owned Iron Dome missile defense batteries and efforts to transfer those systems to Ukraine. The senators contend that Israel’s role in existing cooperative production arrangements affected Washington’s ability to provide those systems to Ukrainian forces.
That account forms part of the senators’ argument against expanding similar arrangements into additional weapons programs. It does not establish that every proposed joint development agreement would impose comparable restrictions.
The proposed defense initiative has already generated opposition beyond the Senate. In September, dozens of civil rights and advocacy organizations urged Congress to remove the House provision, raising concerns involving sensitive military technology, foreign policy accountability and the implications of expanding military cooperation during continuing regional conflicts.
An earlier attempt in the House to remove the provision was unsuccessful, leaving the proposed technology initiative in the legislation approved by that chamber.
The dispute also intersects with an evolving discussion over the financial and industrial structure of American military assistance to Israel.
For decades, the United States has provided substantial security assistance to Israel through military financing, weapons transfers, missile defense programs and cooperative development agreements. The existing 10-year bilateral assistance framework extends through fiscal year 2028 and provides for approximately $3.8 billion annually in military assistance, subject to congressional appropriations.
Israeli officials have advocated moving toward a relationship emphasizing joint defense production, technological development and industrial partnerships rather than relying principally on traditional military assistance.
Such a transition could shift portions of the relationship into defense procurement contracts, joint research programs and manufacturing agreements involving American and Israeli companies.
The senators argue that these arrangements warrant careful examination because long-term defense contracts and integrated technology systems can create obligations that remain in place even when political leadership or foreign policy priorities change.
For American defense manufacturers, expanded cooperation could create additional opportunities for research, development and production. It could also introduce questions concerning technology ownership, licensing, supply chains, export restrictions and the ability of the United States to independently manufacture or modify certain weapons systems.
Those considerations are particularly relevant as the Pentagon continues investing in artificial intelligence, advanced computing, autonomous military platforms and other technologies expected to influence future defense capabilities.
The proposed cooperation would involve fields in which American defense officials must balance technological innovation against the protection of classified information, proprietary research and military capabilities.
Wyden’s participation follows his earlier opposition to the 2027 defense authorization legislation. In July, the Oregon senator criticized elements of the defense bill involving military spending, privacy protections and cooperation with Israeli contractors developing surveillance and artificial intelligence technologies.
Merkley’s participation places both Oregon senators among the congressional members seeking to revise the defense legislation before its final passage.
Their position does not amount to a proposal to terminate existing diplomatic relations, cancel all military assistance to Israel or prohibit future defense cooperation. The requested changes concern specific statutory requirements that would expand and formalize additional arrangements.
The broader U.S.-Israel security relationship would remain subject to existing federal law, executive branch decisions, congressional appropriations and applicable bilateral agreements.
The final outcome now rests with congressional negotiations over the defense authorization package. House and Senate negotiators must reconcile competing legislative provisions before a final measure can be presented for approval by both chambers.
The National Defense Authorization Act establishes defense policy and authorizes military programs, although actual federal spending generally requires separate appropriations legislation. The annual measure encompasses military operations, personnel policies, procurement authorities, national security programs and numerous other responsibilities affecting the Department of Defense.
As of November 16, the disputed provisions remain subjects of congressional negotiation, and no agreement to remove them has been confirmed.
The outcome will determine whether Congress establishes additional requirements for U.S.-Israel defense technology development and intelligence cooperation or preserves greater executive branch flexibility to negotiate those arrangements individually.
For Oregon’s congressional delegation, the dispute represents a direct intervention in the direction of American defense policy at a time when the federal government is considering substantial military expenditures, emerging weapons technologies and changing security relationships throughout the Middle East.
With the final defense legislation still under negotiation, Wyden and Merkley are seeking to prevent the proposed expansion of military and intelligence cooperation from becoming a statutory obligation, leaving the future scope of those arrangements to subsequent national security decisions and congressional action.

